Friday, April 23, 2010

Similar

The previous book I read was Speak it was about a teenage girl that was raped and kept quiet about it. My currrent Lit circle book is about a young girl named Bone who is repeatly raped and tells her mother about it but her mother does not take the correct course of actions. Both books deal with young girls being raped and each of these girls deal with it in completely sepreate ways. These books are written by different authors in very different writting styles. Both novel's deal with the taboo and drak subject of rape. In each book both of the main characters grow a lot during the book and go through very long journey's.
Bone has been raped several times. Glen is Bone's step-father, he is her second step-father in 6 years, the first died in a car crash, which left Bone's mother alone with Bone and a new born. Glen rapes and beats Bone on several occasions. When Bone tells her mother what has happened. Anney (her mother) talks to Glen and when he "promises" to "never ever ever do it again", Anney decides to stay with him and keep Bone living in the same house as him. Bone also has to cope with the fact that she lives with her rapist and abuser. Not only does she have to live with Glen but he is "the love of Anney's life". If you really think about it Bone's mother loves the man who causes Bone so much pain both mentally and phiscally. Glen beats her into until she has broken bones and is dripping with blood. Glen is severly distorting what Bone should expect out of an adult in life. As a young girl I would think that I my mother loves the man who causes me so much pain then does my mother love my suffering? What a horrible thing to think that the person who is supposed to love you unconditionally and care for you loves you're own personal hell. Bone does fight back when she is raped but she is not as brutal as Glen is Bone is also a lot smaller than Glen. Bone's aunt finds that Glen has once again raped her and she takes Bone. Anney comes back after disappering and comes back with a new birth certificate with out the "illegitamate" stamp on it. Bone's mother leaves her in the arms of her aunt and uncle and Bone is free to stay at her aunt's house. Bone has new parents a new house a new town and a new brith certificate. Bone is free to live a new life with and aunt and uncle that can love her and support her. Anney has to live with the burdin that she is a mother that is not even living in the same house as her duaghter but living in the house with a man that has raped and beaten her to sever conditions.
Melinda went 9 months without telling one person not even her nerself would talk about it. She never recived the professional help she should have gotten from the beginging as a result she had to struggle and survive 9 months in her own cacoon of depression and lonleyness. Freshman year was a struggle with her rape and so will the rest of her high school career and she will always live with the rape. She was raped over summer and almost raped again at school, her friends completely disowned her and her family had never really been there for support. She feels guilty about what has happened to her even though she has done nothing wrong. She has fallen into the trap that many rape victims do and she can not get out by herself. She is obviously falling deeper and deeper in to depression and she has isolated her self in the janitor closet. She has locked her self in a tower and does not seem to be waiting to be saved. Melinda does not want to overexasgerate her sitcuation or make it worse by having to defend that it actually did happen, Melinda is afraid no one will support her. Melinda is coping with depression on a daily bases for over 9 months and has no help. The fact that she is a lone and depressed is making her even more depressed which helps with the exponential down spiral of her depression. Melinda has given everyone around her the signs that she is depressed which is a built in safety system of the disease. Mel is used to being ignored by her parents and got most of her needed attention from her friends but now she has no friends leaving her with absolutly no where to turn. Andy tries to rape her again and and she screams Melinda is determined not to get raped again she takes a peice of glass and holds it to his neck. With her tightening grip she was determinded not to be a victim again. Her being raped is all Melinda could think about for these past 9 months. Melinda has come full circle she started the year alone with no defence to the outside world and has worked her way up to some one with a very weak defense system. She has milled over the moment she was raped thinking about what she would do different and she got that second chance. Melinda gained back most of her old life after the second rape incident, her friends forgive her for calling the cops and she can talk to people about her mounding issues.
Each girl had thier own journey through life and in Bastard out of Carolina Anney also had to devlope, but both books show the journey of a raped young girl. Bone still has to live with the fact that her rapeist has no concesquences at all and lives with her mother. Melinda gets to know that the person who antaginoized her for 9 months is punished and she does not have to live life alone. Bone and Melinda are one of the many girls who are raped.
Not part of the monthly review but, One in four women are raped by college and most do not report it, only one in thirty three men are raped by college

No comments:

Post a Comment